Inserting missing records using multiple fields as the key

Question

Post reply

Inserting missing records using multiple fields as the key

christy-720576

SSC Veteran

Points: 239
More actions
April 8, 2013 at 5:00 am

#292119

Hi,
I have a complex problem that I'm pretty sure should have a very simple solution. If I could just find it.
I am trying to import data from a flat file aka Raw_Build_List:
Contract Description varchar(30)
Section Description varchar(25)
Item Description varchar(30)
Quantity integer
I am trying to write a script that will pull it into a relational database to use with other data. The script will have to run every night. The Raw data may contain records processed before.
I have 4 tables:
Contracts (ID, Contract_Description, etc),
Sections (ID, Section, etc),
Items (ID, Description, Category, etc) and
Build_list (ContractID, SectionID, ItemID, Qty, StartDate, etc)
To import the data I do multiple steps.
1. Add 3 extra fields to Raw_Build_List: ContractID, SectionID and ItemID.
2. I run a conditional insert into each table (Contracts, Sections and Items) using a group by eg.
INSERT INTO Contracts (Contract_Description)
SELECT ContractDesctiption
GROUP BY ContractDesctiption
WHERE ContractDescription NOT IN (SELECT Contract_Description FROM Contracts)
3. Then using the IDs generated by the Identity Fields I update the new fields in the Raw_Build_List table. eg.
UPDATE Raw_Build_List
SET ContractID = ID
FROM Contracts LEFT OUTER JOIN Raw_Build_List
ON Contracts.Contract_Description = Raw_Build_List.ContractDesctiption
4. Now in the Raw_Build_List I have all the key fields against all the correct descriptions and I want to put all those keys into the Build_list table and not create duplicates.
Is there a non-RBAR way of doing this?
The one way I thought may work is to string all the IDs together and compare them to the string of all the IDs in the other table and it does work but as expected is really slow. RIGHT('00000000'+LTRIM(RTRIM(ContractID))+RIGHT('00000000'+LTRIM(RTRIM(SectionID))+RIGHT('00000000'+LTRIM(RTRIM(ItemID))
NOTE: I had to pad it as Contract=1, Section=24 and Item=45 (joined = 12445) will match up with Contract=12, Section=44 and Item 5 (joined = 12445).
There has to be a better way of doing this...:blink:

Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic. Login to reply

ChrisM@Work SSC Guru Points: 186127 More actions · Answer 1

Does this help?

-- set up some sample data

DROP TABLE #Contracts

CREATE TABLE #Contracts (ID INT IDENTITY, Contract_Description VARCHAR(50), StartDate DATETIME)

DROP TABLE #Sections

CREATE TABLE #Sections (ID INT IDENTITY, Section VARCHAR(50))

DROP TABLE #Items

CREATE TABLE #Items (ID INT IDENTITY, [Description] VARCHAR(50), Qty INT)

DROP TABLE #Build_list

CREATE TABLE #Build_list (

ContractID INT,

SectionID INT,

ItemID INT,

Contract_Description varchar(30),

Section_Description varchar(25),

Item_Description varchar(30),

Qty INT,

StartDate DATETIME)

INSERT INTO #Build_list (Contract_Description, Section_Description, Item_Description, Qty, StartDate)

SELECT 'Contract 1', 'Section 1', 'Item 1', 10, GETDATE()-22 UNION ALL

SELECT 'Contract 2', 'Section 2', 'Item 2', 20, GETDATE()-21 UNION ALL

SELECT 'Contract 3', 'Section 3', 'Item 3', 30, GETDATE()-20 UNION ALL

SELECT 'Contract 3', 'Section 3', 'Item 3', 40, GETDATE()-19 UNION ALL

SELECT 'Contract 4', 'Section 4', 'Item 4', 50, GETDATE()-18 UNION ALL

SELECT 'Contract 5', 'Section 5', 'Item 5', 60, GETDATE()-17

-- create a table to receive OUTPUT rows

DROP TABLE #InsertedContracts

CREATE TABLE #InsertedContracts (ID INT, Contract_Description VARCHAR(50), StartDate DATETIME)

-- insert distinct new values from source table into contract table,

-- output new ID's etc into temp table

-- Contract_Description, StartDate are keys for markback

INSERT INTO #Contracts (Contract_Description, StartDate)

OUTPUT inserted.ID, inserted.Contract_Description, inserted.StartDate INTO #InsertedContracts

SELECT

Contract_Description,

StartDate

FROM (

SELECT

Contract_Description,

StartDate,

rn = ROW_NUMBER() OVER(PARTITION BY Contract_Description ORDER BY StartDate)

FROM #Build_list b

WHERE NOT EXISTS(SELECT 1 FROM #Contracts c WHERE c.Contract_Description = b.Contract_Description)

) s

WHERE rn = 1

-- markback source table

UPDATE b SET ContractID = c.ID

FROM #Build_list b

INNER JOIN #InsertedContracts c

ON c.Contract_Description = b.Contract_Description AND c.StartDate = b.StartDate

-- check results

SELECT * FROM #Build_list

SELECT * FROM #Contracts

/* a future release of SQL Server will allow you to do this in one step using composable dml:

UPDATE b SET ContractID = c.ID

FROM #Build_list b

INNER JOIN (

INSERT INTO #Contracts (Contract_Description, StartDate)

OUTPUT inserted.ID, inserted.Contract_Description, inserted.StartDate INTO #InsertedContracts

SELECT

Contract_Description,

StartDate

FROM (

SELECT

Contract_Description,

StartDate,

rn = ROW_NUMBER() OVER(PARTITION BY Contract_Description ORDER BY StartDate)

FROM #Build_list b

WHERE NOT EXISTS(SELECT 1 FROM #Contracts c WHERE c.Contract_Description = b.Contract_Description)

) s

WHERE rn = 1

) c (ID, Contract_Description, StartDate)

ON c.Contract_Description = b.Contract_Description AND c.StartDate = b.StartDate

*/

^{“Write the query the simplest way. If through testing it becomes clear that the performance is inadequate, consider alternative query forms.” - Gail Shaw}

For fast, accurate and documented assistance in answering your questions, please read this article.
Understanding and using APPLY, (I) and (II) Paul White
Hidden RBAR: Triangular Joins / The "Numbers" or "Tally" Table: What it is and how it replaces a loop Jeff Moden

christy-720576 SSC Veteran Points: 239 More actions · Answer 2

Not really let me put a full copy of the example:

--Okay Slightly different sample data

DROP TABLE Contracts

CREATE TABLE Contracts (ID INT IDENTITY, Contract_Description VARCHAR(50), StartDate DATETIME)

DROP TABLE Sections

CREATE TABLE Sections (ID INT IDENTITY, Section VARCHAR(50))

DROP TABLE Items

CREATE TABLE Items (ID INT IDENTITY, [Description] VARCHAR(50), Category VARCHAR(15))

DROP TABLE Build_list

CREATE TABLE Build_list (

ContractID INT,

SectionID INT,

ItemID INT,

Qty INT,

FlagCollect BIT)

DROP TABLE Raw_Build_list

CREATE TABLE Raw_Build_list (

Contract_Description varchar(30),

Section_Description varchar(25),

Item_Description varchar(30),

Qty INT)

INSERT INTO Raw_Build_list (Contract_Description, Section_Description, Item_Description, Qty)

SELECT 'Build Car 1', 'Trunk', 'Trunk Latch', 2

UNION ALL SELECT 'Build Car 1', 'Trunk', 'Cover', 1

UNION ALL SELECT 'Build Car 1', 'Drivers Side', 'Front Door', 1

UNION ALL SELECT 'Build Car 1', 'Drivers Side', 'Indicator', 2

UNION ALL SELECT 'Build Car 1', 'Drivers Side', 'Handle', 2

UNION ALL SELECT 'Build Car 1', 'Passenger Side', 'Front Door', 1

UNION ALL SELECT 'Build Car 2', 'Trunk', 'Latch', 2

UNION ALL SELECT 'Build Car 2', 'Trunk', 'Cover', 1

UNION ALL SELECT 'Build Car 2', 'Drivers Side', 'Front Door', 1

UNION ALL SELECT 'Build Car 2', 'Drivers Side', 'Back Slide Door', 1

UNION ALL SELECT 'Build Car 2', 'Drivers Side', 'Indicator', 2

UNION ALL SELECT 'Build Car 2', 'Drivers Side', 'Handle', 2

UNION ALL SELECT 'Build Car 2', 'Passenger Side', 'Front Door',1

INSERT INTO Contracts (Contract_Description, StartDate)

SELECT 'Build Car 1', GETDATE()- 12

INSERT INTO Sections (Section)

SELECT 'Trunk' UNION ALL

SELECT 'Drivers Side' UNION ALL

SELECT 'Passenger Side'

INSERT INTO Items (Description, Category)

SELECT 'Front Door', 'BODY WORK' UNION ALL

SELECT 'Trunk Latch', 'SMALLS' UNION ALL

SELECT 'Cover', 'BODY WORK' UNION ALL

SELECT 'Indicator', 'LIGHTS' UNION ALL

SELECT 'Handle', 'SMALLS'

INSERT INTO Build_list (ContractID, SectionID, ItemID, Qty)

SELECT 1, 1, 2, 2

UNION ALL SELECT 1, 1, 3, 1

UNION ALL SELECT 1, 2, 1, 1

UNION ALL SELECT 1, 2, 4, 2

UNION ALL SELECT 1, 2, 5, 2

--SELECT * FROM Contracts

--SELECT * FROM Sections

--SELECT * FROM Items

--SELECT * FROM Build_list

--SELECT * FROM Raw_Build_list

--HERE IS WHERE THE WORK STARTS

ALTER TABLE Raw_Build_List ADD ContractID bigint

ALTER TABLE Raw_Build_List ADD SectionID bigint

ALTER TABLE Raw_Build_List ADD ItemID bigint

--INSERT ALL THE CONTRACTS

INSERT INTO Contracts (Contract_Description)

SELECT Contract_Description

FROM Raw_Build_list

GROUP BY Contract_Description

HAVING (NOT (Contract_Description IN

(SELECT Contract_Description

FROM Contracts)))

--UPDATE ID FIELD FOR CONTRACTS

UPDATE Raw_Build_list

SET ContractID = Contracts.ID

FROM Contracts LEFT OUTER JOIN

Raw_Build_list ON Contracts.Contract_Description = Raw_Build_list.Contract_Description

--INSERT ALL THE SECTIONS

INSERT INTO Sections (Section)

SELECT Section_Description

FROM Raw_Build_list

GROUP BY Section_Description

HAVING (NOT (Section_Description IN

(SELECT Section

FROM Sections)))

--UPDATE ID FIELD FOR SECTIONS

UPDATE Raw_Build_list

SET SectionID = Sections.ID

FROM Sections LEFT OUTER JOIN

Raw_Build_list ON Sections.Section = Raw_Build_list.Section_Description

--INSERT ALL THE ITEMS

INSERT INTO Items (Description)

SELECT Item_Description

FROM Raw_Build_list

GROUP BY Item_Description

HAVING (NOT (Item_Description IN

(SELECT Description

FROM Items)))

--UPDATE ID FIELD FOR ITEMS

UPDATE Raw_Build_list

SET ItemID = Items.ID

FROM Items LEFT OUTER JOIN

Raw_Build_list ON Items.Description = Raw_Build_list.Item_Description

--NOW THIS WORKS BUT IS VERY, VERY SLOW __THERE HAS TO BE A BETTER WAY TO DO THIS

INSERT INTO Build_list

(ContractID, SectionID, ItemID, Qty)

SELECT ContractID, SectionID, ItemID, Qty

FROM Raw_Build_list

WHERE ((RIGHT('000000' + LTRIM(RTRIM(ContractID)), 6) + RIGHT('000000' + LTRIM(RTRIM(SectionID)), 6) + RIGHT('000000' + LTRIM(RTRIM(ItemID)), 6)) NOT IN

(SELECT RIGHT('000000' + LTRIM(RTRIM(ContractID)), 6) + RIGHT('000000' + LTRIM(RTRIM(SectionID)), 6) + RIGHT('000000' + LTRIM(RTRIM(ItemID)), 6)

AS Joinid

FROM Build_list))

--The results of these two queries should be identical

SELECT Contract_Description, Section_Description, Item_Description, Qty

FROM Raw_Build_list

SELECT Contracts.Contract_Description, Sections.Section, Items.Description, Build_list.Qty

FROM Build_list LEFT OUTER JOIN

Items ON Build_list.ItemID = Items.ID LEFT OUTER JOIN

Sections ON Build_list.SectionID = Sections.ID LEFT OUTER JOIN

Contracts ON Build_list.ContractID = Contracts.ID

Mark Cowne One Orange Chip Points: 26952 More actions · Answer 3

Try changing

INSERT INTO Build_list

(ContractID, SectionID, ItemID, Qty)

SELECT ContractID, SectionID, ItemID, Qty

FROM Raw_Build_list

WHERE ((RIGHT('000000' + LTRIM(RTRIM(ContractID)), 6) + RIGHT('000000' + LTRIM(RTRIM(SectionID)), 6) + RIGHT('000000' + LTRIM(RTRIM(ItemID)), 6)) NOT IN

(SELECT RIGHT('000000' + LTRIM(RTRIM(ContractID)), 6) + RIGHT('000000' + LTRIM(RTRIM(SectionID)), 6) + RIGHT('000000' + LTRIM(RTRIM(ItemID)), 6)

AS Joinid

FROM Build_list))

to

INSERT INTO Build_list

(ContractID, SectionID, ItemID, Qty)

SELECT ContractID, SectionID, ItemID, Qty

FROM Raw_Build_list

EXCEPT

SELECT ContractID, SectionID, ItemID, Qty

FROM Build_list

____________________________________________________

Deja View - The strange feeling that somewhere, sometime you've optimised this query before

How to get the best help on a forum

http://www.sqlservercentral.com/articles/Best+Practices/61537

christy-720576 SSC Veteran Points: 239 More actions · Answer 4

Thanks Mark that is exactly what I'm looking for!

Simple and fast!

😀