Query returning different count of rows in Enterprise and Standard

  • I have a query where I have to select a image column with group by. When I am trying to do that its giving the below error.

    Msg 306, Level 16, State 2, Line 1

    The text, ntext, and image data types cannot be compared or sorted, except when using IS NULL or LIKE operator.

    As a workaround I had put the query without image column in select and group by clauses in a dervied table and used a join condition. The problem now is when i execute the query in Standard edition instead of returning 1000 rows its returning some millions of rows. Whereas if I execute the same query in enterprise edition its working fine. Both are RTM versions only.

    Initial query

    select tbl1.col1,tbl2.col1,tbl1.imgcol,tbl1.colx

    from table1 tbl1,table2 tbl2

    where tbl1.colx=tbl2.coly

    group by tbl1.col1,tbl2.col1,tbl1.imgcol,tbl1.colx

    order by tbl1.col1

    Workaround query

    select d.*,o.imgcol

    from

    (

    select tbl1.col1,tbl2.col1,tbl1.colx

    from table1 tbl1,table2 tbl2

    where tbl1.colx=tbl2.coly

    group by tbl1.col1,tbl2.col1,tbl1.colx

    ) as d,tbl1 o

    where d.colx=o.colx

    Please help me

    [font="Verdana"]Thanks
    Chandra Mohan[/font]

  • The problem is that these queries may not be equivalent. What is the relationship between table1 and table2, is it a one to many relationship?

    Some sample data for the relavent columns in each table (except the image columns) would help in visualize the relationship. Be sure the data is represtative of the data in your tables. Don't provide just one or two records for each table, but enough to give an idea of the data. In place of the image column, you might provide an integer value that represents each image. Duplicate images should have the same value so that we can see if there are duplicate images in the records.

  • Can you post actual execution plans for each of the queries?

    Since you're testing it on two different servers, are you 100% positive that the same data exists in each? Also, be sure that both databases have their indexes fragmented and the statistics updated in the same manner. Any of this can change the execution plans generated, although it usually won't affect the data returned.

    "The credit belongs to the man who is actually in the arena, whose face is marred by dust and sweat and blood"
    - Theodore Roosevelt

    Author of:
    SQL Server Execution Plans
    SQL Server Query Performance Tuning

Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 2 (of 2 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic. Login to reply